Marianna Palka

The Woman

Jason Ritter

The Man

Eric Edelstein

Eric

Martin Starr

Simon

Mark Webber

Derek

Tom Arnold

Dad

Amanda Barnett

Restaurant Patron

Charles Durning

Charlie

Seth Gabel

Kissing Man

Bryce Dallas Howard

Kissing Woman

Jesse Garcia

Jose

Marge Morgan

Old Woman

Tyler Ritter

Young Handsome Man

Dana LaRue

Receptionist

Jeremy Glazer

Café Patron

Hadrian Belove

Cinefile Customer

Hunter Stiebel

Skate Clerk

Jennifer Dubin

Cinefile Customer

Elisabeth Waterston

Elisabeth

Luke Hawes

Cinefile Customer

Katherine Waterston

Katherine

Peter Kloman

Cinefile Customer

Gordon Mahlon

Cinefile Customer

Cora Olson

Cinefile Customer

Doug Roy

Cinefile Customer

Mitch Yapko

Cinefile Customer

Albert Atri

Ice Skater

Scott Crichton

Ice Skater

Curtis Harrison

Ice Skater

Marty Laquidara

Ice Skater

James LeNouail

Ice Skater

Mike McNeil

Ice Skater

Adam Mitchell

Ice Skater

Steve Poplawski

Ice Skater

Perry Smiley

Ice Skater

Tracy White

Ice Skater

Michael Cole

Pedestrian

Rye Shelton

Pedestrian

Jason Kennedy

Restaurant Patron

John Monsour

Restaurant Patron

Leslie Monsour

Restaurant Patron

Nancy Morgan

Waitress

Amberlee Colson

Elle (uncredited)

Josh Holt

Jared (uncredited)