Kadro (38)
Kimberly Williams-PaisleyIda Graber
Tammy BlanchardAmy Roberts
Fay MastersonJill Green
Madison MasonLevi Brennaman
Gary GrahamHenry Taskey
Darcy Rose ByrnesRebecca Knepp
Karley Scott CollinsKatie Graber
Eugene ByrdDanny
Bruce NozickLeonard
Amy SloanRachel Knepp
John ChurchillCharlie Roberts
Madison DavenportMary Beth Graber
Matt LetscherGideon Graber
Eric NenningerState Trooper
Willow GeerJudith
Christopher CurryMinister
Kate FugleiShelly
Jim MetzlerSheriff
Bob RumnockReporter
Emilee WallaceTeacher Ruth
Jessica DickeyMelindaChloe MadisonSarah Knepp
Taylor Ann ThompsonHannah
Trevor ThompsonJacob
David MazouzAndy Roberts
Dale Wade DavisRachel's Husband
Joel SchmidtMelinda's HusbandDavid CurtisAmish Elder
Sammy JackKnepp Boy #1Gabriel WelchKnepp Boy #2Elijah TadrosRyan Roberts
Caleb BabcockSchoolboy (uncredited)
Daphne BluntLilly (uncredited)Rick L. DeanState Trooper (uncredited)
Paul EdneyNews Cameraman (uncredited)Isabella InterianLydia (uncredited)Marcus ShultzKnepp Teenager (uncredited)Johnny WilsonSheriff's Deputy (uncredited)